View Our Practice Areas

Ruling says athletes may sue for concussion-related injuries

If you are a high school or college athlete, or are a parent of one, a new opinion that just came from the Ninth Circuit may be of interest to you since it asks for more protection of athletes from devastating head injuries.

In this particular ruling, a federal appeals court said that the governing body for the USA Water Polo organization is able to be sued for not protecting an athlete who was allowed to continue to play after receiving a concussion.

New ruling could be a wake-up call

Currently, no organization or sports entity can be sued for injuries suffered during play of the sport. Examples of this would include a baseball that his thrown into a batter or a tackle in a football game. Since these actions are an inherent part of the game, repercussions are not allowed to be sought due to an injury.

However, in this case, a female water polo player who was hit directly in the face with the ball went to her coach soon afterwards. According to the ruling, the blow to her head from the ball resulted in a concussion. However, her coach sent her back out to play where she encountered additional shots to the head which exacerbated the original injury. The court said that USA Water Polo is responsible for the protection of athletes from receiving repeated head injuries. The organization argued that rules it implemented for their coaches fulfilled that responsibility, but the court rejected that claim.

Complications from the head injury

Two days following the injuries in the pool, the player began dealing with severe headaches and suffered fatigue. The health of the player became so bad that she was unable to attend school where she had previously been a 4.0 student and played multiple sports. Her diagnosis was said to be post-concussion syndrome and that she had suffered declining mental capacity.

What this may mean for future athletes

Since this ruling was not about the initial injury that was sustained, but for the resulting injuries that happened when the coach let her play, all sports may begin to look at head injuries more closely during play. This ruling may make coaches and training personnel more cognizant about the severity of a head injury before letting their players back into the action, and not just in water polo, but in all sports.

This decision could cause sports organizations to implement protocols before letting a player back into a game after suffering a head injury. If you are an athlete or you have a son or daughter who is an athlete, you may want to check with the organization regarding their policy for determining head injuries during game play.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Schedule A Free Consultation

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Sacramento Office
20 Bicentennial Circle
Sacramento, CA 95826

Toll Free: 800-598-7160
Phone: 916-379-3500
Fax: 916-379-3599
Sacramento Law Office Map

San Jose Office
177 Park Avenue
Suite 200
San Jose, CA 95113

Toll Free: 800-598-7160
Phone: 408-286-5800
Fax: 408-275-1331
Map & Directions

Auburn Office
195 Cherry Avenue
Auburn, CA 95603

Toll Free: 800-598-7160
Phone: 530-889-1800
Fax: 530-889-1807
Map & Directions